Screen Repair vs Replacement: How to Know Which One You Need
Do you likely asked yourself: screen repair vs replacement—what’s the right call? It’s a common question we hear from homeowners looking to improve airflow, keep pests out, and upgrade the look and function of their home.
This guide will walk you through the most common types of screen damage, how to evaluate repair versus replacement, and when it’s time to bring in a professional. As a trusted mobile screen service with over 20 years of hands-on experience,
Screen Master Door & Window is here to help you make the best decision for your home and budget.
Understanding Common Types
of Screen Damage
Knowing what kind of damage you’re dealing with is the first step toward choosing between repair or replacement. Some issues are simple fixes, others may signal it’s time for a full upgrade.
Tears and Holes in the Mesh
Small tears—typically under an inch—can be patched or re-screened easily. However, large rips, pet-related damage, or frayed edges across multiple areas are better handled with a full mesh replacement.
Warped or Bent Frames
A screen frame that doesn’t sit flush in the window or door frame can lead to poor sealing and a loose fit. Warping is often caused by weather exposure, physical damage, or simply aging materials. When the frame is bent or rusted, repair options are limited.
Sagging or Loose Screens
Mesh that sags or has lost tension may indicate the spline (rubber cord) is worn out. While re-splining is often an option, screens that have repeatedly lost tension are usually ready for replacement.
Screen Repair vs Screen Replacement: What’s the Difference?
Let’s break down the basics of
screen repair vs replacement.
| Screen Repair | Screen Replacement | |
|---|---|---|
| Mesh damage | Minor holes or tears | Large rips or heavy wear |
| Frame condition | Intact and aligned | Warped, bent, or rusted |
| Cost | Lower upfront cost | Higher, long-term value |
| Lifespan extension | Short-term fix | Full refresh |
| Aesthetic update | Limited | Full design upgrade |
Repair involves fixing specific issues, replacing mesh, tightening corners, or fixing spline. Replacement involves installing a brand-new screen, often custom-sized, with updated materials and frame integrity.
Comparing Screen Repair vs Screen Replacement Costs
Understanding the financial aspect helps make a confident decision. The cost difference between screen repair vs screen replacement depends on the severity of the damage, the screen type, and your home's unique needs.
Repair Costs
Simple mesh re-screens or patch jobs usually cost less—ranging between $20 to $40 per window screen, depending on mesh type and screen size.
Replacement Costs
A full replacement, especially for doors or oversized windows, may cost $50 to $150 or more. This includes custom-fit frames, upgraded mesh options (like pet-resistant or solar mesh), and professional installation.
At Screen Master, we offer free quotes and on-site assessments so you’ll know exactly what your home needs before making a decision.
Factors That Help You Decide
Material Type Matters
• Fiberglass mesh: Budget-friendly and flexible, but prone to sagging over time
• Aluminum mesh: Stronger and more durable, but may crease
• Pet-resistant mesh: Ideal for active households but slightly more costly
• Solar screens: Reduce UV exposure and energy costs but may reduce airflow
If you’re unsure what type you have, we’ll identify it on-site and recommend the best match.
Screen Age & Condition
If your screens are over 8–10 years old and showing signs of rust, looseness, or general wear, a replacement may be more cost-effective in the long run. Repairs on brittle or outdated materials often don’t last.
Environmental Factors
In sunny climates like Southern California, UV damage is a big concern. Screens exposed to full sun, coastal air, or frequent windstorms may degrade faster. We offer UV-resistant and coastal-grade materials designed to withstand local conditions.
How Long Will Each Option Last?
Repaired Screens
A professional repair can add another 1–3 years to a screen’s lifespan—perfect if the frame is in good shape and you’re not ready for a full replacement.
New Screens
With upgraded materials and better frame construction, replacement screens can last 10–15 years or more, especially with proper maintenance. Our replacements are built using USA-quality materials designed for long-term durability.
When to Call in a Professional
DIY kits may seem like a quick solution, but screen work requires precision. Misaligned frames, poorly tensioned mesh, or incorrect spline sizing often lead to frustrating results. You’ll want expert help if:
• Your screen no longer fits securely in the frame
• The frame is warped, rusted, or broken
• You’ve attempted a fix that didn’t hold
• You’re dealing with multiple damaged screens
Screen Master brings our workshop to your doorstep with mobile tools, custom materials, and same-day turnaround in many cases. Our technicians will walk you through the best options—no guesswork required.
Explore Custom Screen Solutions with Screen Master
Whether you’re updating your home, prepping for summer, or replacing a broken screen, we offer fully customizable options for every type of property:
• Sliding patio doors
• Retractable or swinging screen doors
• Pet door inserts and pet-proof mesh
• Security screen doors with tamper-resistant frames
• Solar and privacy mesh
Our mobile service covers Los Angeles County and surrounding areas, so we can measure, build, and install without disrupting your schedule. Explore our security screen options here.
Let Screen Master Handle Your Screen Repair vs Replacement Needs
Still not sure which is best—screen repair vs replacement? You’re not alone. Every screen issue is unique, and the right decision depends on damage, materials, and your long-term plans. That’s why we’re here. Screen Master Door & Window provides expert guidance, affordable solutions, and custom-built screens that match your home and lifestyle.
We make it easy. No showroom visit required. We’ll come to your home, assess the damage, and walk you through repair or replacement options—fast, honest, and on your terms.
Contact us for a free quote. We proudly serve Los Angeles, Pasadena, Burbank, El Monte, and surrounding communities.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do you offer mobile screen repair services in Los Angeles?
Yes, Screen Master brings our shop to your doorstep anywhere in the Greater Los Angeles area. Our mobile team provides on-site screen repairs, replacements, and custom solutions—often completed the same day.
Can you fix a bent or warped screen door frame, or do I need a full replacement?
We’ll inspect the frame on-site to determine if it can be realigned or reinforced. If the damage is too severe, we offer custom-built replacement frames to fit your door precisely and restore full functionality.
Do you replace patio screen doors and sliding screens in older LA homes?
Absolutely. We specialize in retrofitting screen doors for older properties, including sliding patio doors, French doors, and custom-size openings. Our screens are made to fit and built to last using quality materials.
How do I know if I should repair or replace my window screens?
If the mesh has minor damage and the frame is in good shape, a repair might be all you need. For rusted, warped, or outdated screens, a replacement is usually more cost-effective. We’ll assess and recommend the best option during our visit.
What areas do you service around Los Angeles?
We proudly serve a wide range of neighborhoods, including Burbank, El Monte, Pasadena, Glendale, and more. If you're unsure whether we cover your area, just give us a call—we're happy to help.
